The Supreme Court heard arguments yesterday on whether the Defense of Marriage Act is constitutional. The session capped two days of arguments which could determine the future of same sex marriages in the United States.
Five of the Justices questioned the constitutionality of the law, noting that the issue of marriage has traditionally been an issue reserved to the states. However, other justces questioned whether proponents of the law had standing to bring the challenge to the Supreme Court. This gave rise to a possibility that the Supreme Court will not itself rule on the constitutionality of the Act, but instead let the Second Circuit case of Windsor v. United States stand. In Windsor, the Second Circuit found the Defense of Marriage Act unconstitutional.
The Defense of Marriage Act defines marriage for federal law purposes as a union between one man and one woman. As a result of the Act, legal benefits available to heterosexual married couples are not available to same sex legal unions.
The case itself involves the availability of the marital deduction in calculating the federal estate tax when the decedant was one spouse in a legal same sex marriage. By striking down the law as unconstitutional, the Second Circuit permitted a same sex spouse to benefit from the marital deduction and thus lower the estate's federal estate tax.
If the Act were struck down, it would have far-reaching implications from federal employee benefits to estate planning to possibly even immigration benefits.
On the day before, the Supreme Court held arguments on California's Proposition 8, which outlawed same sex marriages in California. On that case, the Justices appeard to be sharply divided. As with the argument over the Defense of Marriage Act, there appeared to be a real possibility that the Court would dismiss the case on a technicality ground, allowing a Ninth Circuit decision that found Proposition 8 unconstitutional stand.
By: William J. Kovatch, Jr.
(703) 837-8832
info@kovatchelderlaw.com
Showing posts with label estate planning. Show all posts
Showing posts with label estate planning. Show all posts
Thursday, March 28, 2013
Friday, October 19, 2012
Second Circuit Finds that U.S. Government Cannot Discriminate Against Legal Same-Sex Marriages in Applying the Estate Tax
The U.S. Court of Appeals struck down the Defense of Marriage Act in the case of Windsor v. United States. Specifically, the Court found that section 3 of the Act, which defines marriage as the legal union between one man and one woman, violated the Equal Protection Clause of the Constitution.
The case involved a same-sex couple who had legally married in Canada, and lived in New York. One spouse died, leaving the other to inherit property. The surviving spouse claim the spousal deduction for federal estate tax purposes, which was disallowed under the Defense of Marriage Act. As a result, the estate tax bill amounted to over $300,000.
Under the Court's decision, the Federal Government would be required to recognize legal same-sex marriages when applying the federal estate tax. In some respects, the Court's decision could be far-reaching, as legal same-sex marriages would have to be treated equally to heterosexual marriages for a variety of federal laws and programs, such as Social Security benefits, family leave and employee benefits. On the other hand, the Second Circuit has jurisdiction only over Connecticut, New York and Vermont. The only other federal court to find the Defense of Marriage Act to be unconstitutional is the First Circuit. For the rest of the country, the Defense of Marriage Act remains the law of the land. Nonetheless, the Second Circuit's decision makes it more likely that the U.S. Supreme Court will hear a case involving the Defense of Marriage Act.
I go into more detail in this article.
A New York Times article on the decision can be found here.
The text of the decision can be found here.
By: William J. Kovatch, Jr.
(703) 837-8832
info@kovatchelderlaw.com
The case involved a same-sex couple who had legally married in Canada, and lived in New York. One spouse died, leaving the other to inherit property. The surviving spouse claim the spousal deduction for federal estate tax purposes, which was disallowed under the Defense of Marriage Act. As a result, the estate tax bill amounted to over $300,000.
Under the Court's decision, the Federal Government would be required to recognize legal same-sex marriages when applying the federal estate tax. In some respects, the Court's decision could be far-reaching, as legal same-sex marriages would have to be treated equally to heterosexual marriages for a variety of federal laws and programs, such as Social Security benefits, family leave and employee benefits. On the other hand, the Second Circuit has jurisdiction only over Connecticut, New York and Vermont. The only other federal court to find the Defense of Marriage Act to be unconstitutional is the First Circuit. For the rest of the country, the Defense of Marriage Act remains the law of the land. Nonetheless, the Second Circuit's decision makes it more likely that the U.S. Supreme Court will hear a case involving the Defense of Marriage Act.
I go into more detail in this article.
A New York Times article on the decision can be found here.
The text of the decision can be found here.
By: William J. Kovatch, Jr.
(703) 837-8832
info@kovatchelderlaw.com
Friday, May 25, 2012
We Specialize in Small Estates
Are the executor or personal representative on a Virginia estate worth more than $50,000, but less than $200,000? These estates are particularly troublesome, because you still have to file inventories and accountings, and pay the Commissioner of Accounts filing fees as well.
We specialize in assisting with small estates, and doing it at a price that is reasonable. We have a good working relationship with a fiduciary accountant who can prepare the filings at an hourly rate that is lower than an attorney's rate. Attorney rates will only be charged for court proceedings, and reviewing the filings before they are submitted to the Commissioner of Accounts Office.
If you are responsible for an estate that is worth less than $200,000, contact William J. Kovatch, Jr. now for help.
We specialize in assisting with small estates, and doing it at a price that is reasonable. We have a good working relationship with a fiduciary accountant who can prepare the filings at an hourly rate that is lower than an attorney's rate. Attorney rates will only be charged for court proceedings, and reviewing the filings before they are submitted to the Commissioner of Accounts Office.
If you are responsible for an estate that is worth less than $200,000, contact William J. Kovatch, Jr. now for help.
Thursday, August 11, 2011
Article on Why Women Need to Do Estate Planning
More and more of the clients coming to me to consult about estate planning are women, which I think is a good sign. Whether it's to plan after a divorce, to protect from the credit problems of a spouse, or just to make sure that minor children are protected in the event of something tragic, it is extremely important that women explore their options and take action. This article in Forbes is a good explanation of the importance of estate planning.
Labels:
estate planning,
trust minor children,
wills,
women
Tuesday, May 25, 2010
Planning for Adults with No Children
Recently in my practice, I have noticed something of a trend. That trend is the growing number of older adults who are single, childless and seeking estate planning advice. There are a host of reasons why they are single and childless. Some may have gone through a divorce and never remarried. Some may have been widowed. Some may have focused so much on their careers that they simply never married and had children.
Planning for this set of the population presents some special challenges. The first of such challenges is determining who to choose to serve in various positions of trust, called fiduciaries. Often, when you have a married couple with mature adult children, the couple will look first to the adult children to serve in such positions as executor, trustee or health care agent. When you have an older adult who does not have any children, however, the choice of who shall serve in these positions is not as obvious.
When the single older adult has siblings, often they will think first of appointing a sibling to serve in a position of trust. This, however, can present some special considerations. First, siblings tend to be relatively close in age. Thus, there is a question of whether the sibling will actually pass away first. This could leave the older adult in need of appointing new fiduciaries when their siblings pass away. There is also the risk that once the older adult passes away, the sibling will be unable to take on the role of fiduciary because of factors such as dementia or other health conditions. These problems can be avoided by having the older adult appoint alternative fiduciaries to serve in the event that their first choice either passes away first, or cannot serve for other reasons.
Another potential problem is that siblings may live in different areas of the country. If the sibling must travel a long distance in order to accept an appointment, that may serve as a disincentive to act. In this regard, the older adult should understand that accepting a fiduciary role is voluntary. Even if a person is named in a legal document, that person can still turn down the role.
In some cases, there may be a niece or nephew who is close, in an emotional sense, to the older adult. Such a person may be a better choice, simply because a niece or nephew is likely younger, and thus more likely to outlive the older adult. But, in some cases nieces and nephews may also live quite a distance away from the older adult. Moreover, if the niece or nephew is appointed as an agent to make health care decisions, there could be question of whether that niece of nephew truly knows what the older person would have wanted.
An older adult could look to friends and co-workers. Again, because people tend to associate with others who are close to them in age, this may not alleviate the concern of who will be the first to pass away. Plus, despite friendship, some people may be hesitant to ask someone who is not a relative to take on the burden of administering their estate, or making health care decisions for them.
There may be no simple solution to the dilemma of appointing fiduciaries. At the very least, there should be alternatives named in case the primary choices are unwilling or unable to serve. But, identifying the people who will serve may take some additional time and consideration.
The next issue is exactly what to do with the older adult’s wealth after death. If the older adult has no children, then there will be no obvious choice to inherit that person’s estate. In some situations, the older adult may have done a great job in planning for retirement. He or she may have valuable retirement accounts and investments. He or she may also own real property.
To whom the estate should be left is a very personal question. This may an opportunity for the older adult to leave a legacy, and thus give much of the estate to charity. Perhaps there is a favorite sibling or nephew to whom the older adult would like to leave a gift. Perhaps the older adult has simply not thought about their distribution plan.
What is certain is that if the older adult does not create an estate plan, the state government will create one for them. When a person has not left a will, or placed his or her property in trust, then that is called intestacy. The intestacy laws will then determine who inherits the person’s property. Intestacy laws vary by jurisdiction. But, they tend to favor relatives. Usually, spouse and/or children are the first choice to inherit the estate. If the older adult has no spouse or children, intestacy laws usually look first to see if there is a surviving parent, then brother or sister. In the end, if there is no one to take the estate, then the property will escheat. That means it will belong to the state. If the older adult is not happy with this plan, then it is imperative that he or she think long and hard about how he or she would want his or her property distributed.
The unique challenges presented by single, older adults without children require greater attention and consideration. Consulting with a professional may be helpful, but it may not answer all of the questions. In the end, the choices in creating an estate plan are very personal, and should match a person’s own goals and values.
Planning for this set of the population presents some special challenges. The first of such challenges is determining who to choose to serve in various positions of trust, called fiduciaries. Often, when you have a married couple with mature adult children, the couple will look first to the adult children to serve in such positions as executor, trustee or health care agent. When you have an older adult who does not have any children, however, the choice of who shall serve in these positions is not as obvious.
When the single older adult has siblings, often they will think first of appointing a sibling to serve in a position of trust. This, however, can present some special considerations. First, siblings tend to be relatively close in age. Thus, there is a question of whether the sibling will actually pass away first. This could leave the older adult in need of appointing new fiduciaries when their siblings pass away. There is also the risk that once the older adult passes away, the sibling will be unable to take on the role of fiduciary because of factors such as dementia or other health conditions. These problems can be avoided by having the older adult appoint alternative fiduciaries to serve in the event that their first choice either passes away first, or cannot serve for other reasons.
Another potential problem is that siblings may live in different areas of the country. If the sibling must travel a long distance in order to accept an appointment, that may serve as a disincentive to act. In this regard, the older adult should understand that accepting a fiduciary role is voluntary. Even if a person is named in a legal document, that person can still turn down the role.
In some cases, there may be a niece or nephew who is close, in an emotional sense, to the older adult. Such a person may be a better choice, simply because a niece or nephew is likely younger, and thus more likely to outlive the older adult. But, in some cases nieces and nephews may also live quite a distance away from the older adult. Moreover, if the niece or nephew is appointed as an agent to make health care decisions, there could be question of whether that niece of nephew truly knows what the older person would have wanted.
An older adult could look to friends and co-workers. Again, because people tend to associate with others who are close to them in age, this may not alleviate the concern of who will be the first to pass away. Plus, despite friendship, some people may be hesitant to ask someone who is not a relative to take on the burden of administering their estate, or making health care decisions for them.
There may be no simple solution to the dilemma of appointing fiduciaries. At the very least, there should be alternatives named in case the primary choices are unwilling or unable to serve. But, identifying the people who will serve may take some additional time and consideration.
The next issue is exactly what to do with the older adult’s wealth after death. If the older adult has no children, then there will be no obvious choice to inherit that person’s estate. In some situations, the older adult may have done a great job in planning for retirement. He or she may have valuable retirement accounts and investments. He or she may also own real property.
To whom the estate should be left is a very personal question. This may an opportunity for the older adult to leave a legacy, and thus give much of the estate to charity. Perhaps there is a favorite sibling or nephew to whom the older adult would like to leave a gift. Perhaps the older adult has simply not thought about their distribution plan.
What is certain is that if the older adult does not create an estate plan, the state government will create one for them. When a person has not left a will, or placed his or her property in trust, then that is called intestacy. The intestacy laws will then determine who inherits the person’s property. Intestacy laws vary by jurisdiction. But, they tend to favor relatives. Usually, spouse and/or children are the first choice to inherit the estate. If the older adult has no spouse or children, intestacy laws usually look first to see if there is a surviving parent, then brother or sister. In the end, if there is no one to take the estate, then the property will escheat. That means it will belong to the state. If the older adult is not happy with this plan, then it is imperative that he or she think long and hard about how he or she would want his or her property distributed.
The unique challenges presented by single, older adults without children require greater attention and consideration. Consulting with a professional may be helpful, but it may not answer all of the questions. In the end, the choices in creating an estate plan are very personal, and should match a person’s own goals and values.
Tuesday, April 27, 2010
“Convenience Accounts”: What Are the Risks?
Some people realize that as they get older they may need some help with their finances. Perhaps they want someone they trust to have the ability to pay their bills if something comes up like an extended hospital stay. So, they add the trusted person’s name to their bank account, creating what some people call “convenience accounts.”
But is this really a wise move? In many case, by adding a person’s name to your bank account, you are making that person a joint owner of your account. That means that the person now has all of the rights and privileges you have with that account. The person could withdraw money, and even add another name to the account.
You may think, “Well, I trust this person. She won’t try to steal from me.” But, that is not really the problem. The problem is with the creditors of your new joint-owner.
For example, let’s say your trusted person gets into a car accident. A lawsuit ensues, and your trusted person is found liable. If she does not have enough insurance or assets of her own, the plaintiff from that lawsuit now has every right to attach your bank account to satisfy the judgment.
Adding a person as a joint owner of your bank account simply opens your money up to additional risk. The same goal can be achieved with a very inexpensive document that also avoids the additional risk. That is the power of attorney.
Through a properly drafted power of attorney you appoint a trusted person to be your agent. Your agent can do everything you have the legal right to do, such as draw checks on your checking account. However, all of your assets remain yours, and do not become the joint assets of your agent. This means that your assets can not be used to satisfy the debts of your agent.
Your lawyer can help you create a power of attorney that is right for you, creating powers for your agent that are as broad or as narrow as you want. You should also consult with your bank, as many banks either have their own power of attorney form or their own rules for appointing a power of attorney. A power of attorney can be an important part of your estate planning package.
But is this really a wise move? In many case, by adding a person’s name to your bank account, you are making that person a joint owner of your account. That means that the person now has all of the rights and privileges you have with that account. The person could withdraw money, and even add another name to the account.
You may think, “Well, I trust this person. She won’t try to steal from me.” But, that is not really the problem. The problem is with the creditors of your new joint-owner.
For example, let’s say your trusted person gets into a car accident. A lawsuit ensues, and your trusted person is found liable. If she does not have enough insurance or assets of her own, the plaintiff from that lawsuit now has every right to attach your bank account to satisfy the judgment.
Adding a person as a joint owner of your bank account simply opens your money up to additional risk. The same goal can be achieved with a very inexpensive document that also avoids the additional risk. That is the power of attorney.
Through a properly drafted power of attorney you appoint a trusted person to be your agent. Your agent can do everything you have the legal right to do, such as draw checks on your checking account. However, all of your assets remain yours, and do not become the joint assets of your agent. This means that your assets can not be used to satisfy the debts of your agent.
Your lawyer can help you create a power of attorney that is right for you, creating powers for your agent that are as broad or as narrow as you want. You should also consult with your bank, as many banks either have their own power of attorney form or their own rules for appointing a power of attorney. A power of attorney can be an important part of your estate planning package.
Friday, February 26, 2010
Blended Families Require Special Estate Planning
If you are part of a blended family, then you may need to do some special estate planning to ensure that your personal goals are met.
A blended family is one where either spouse has children from a prior marriage or relationship. Blended families raise estate planning issues because of the need to balance responsibilities to the current spouse, as well as to the children from the prior relationship.
Without special planning, you may find that you goals are not being met.
For example, in Virginia, where a person is married, but has children from a prior relationship, and that person dies without a will, then one-third of the estate passes to the current spouse, and two-thirds are split among all of the decedent’s children. Notice, by the way, that I specifically said “prior relationship,” and not “prior marriage.” That is in recognition that the law protects illegitimate children as much as legitimate children.
This default estate plan, which is called the law of intestacy, may cause some problems for your surviving loved ones. For example, if you have children from a prior marriage, but they are adults, and your current spouse depends on your income and property, the law of intestacy works against your current spouse.
The solution is to carefully think about your family responsibilities and your estate plan goals, talk about them with your spouse, and work with an estate planning attorney to make your goals happen. Here are some tips on how you may be able to achieve your estate planning goals.
Communicate with Your Spouse
The first step is to make sure that you and your spouse are on the same page. Talk openly about your responsibilities to your children from your prior relationship. Talk about your expectations for any children you may have in your current marriage. Talk about what property rights you have, and how you expect to dispose of those rights on your death.
Conclude a Prenuptial or Marital Agreement
Once you and your current spouse (or, ideally your future spouse) have discussed your respective responsibilities, you should come to an understanding concerning your property. Formalize that understanding with a prenuptial agreement (before the wedding) or marital agreement (after the wedding). In Virginia, a marital agreement is just as valid as a prenuptial agreement.
Many people will resist prenuptial agreements with their future spouses. Some view them as merely planning for an eventual divorce. Some of your friends, or even misinformed attorneys may echo that thought.
A prenuptial or marital agreement, however, is not simply planning for an eventual divorce. Rather, it can be a tool to start the conversation about property and expectations. It can be an opportunity to clarify estate planning goals. Formalizing the expectations in a written agreement can avoid confusion and misunderstandings later in the marriage.
For example, if both spouses are coming into a marriage with their own property, it could be that neither spouse would be dependent on the property of the other after one passes away. In such a situation, the spouses may agree to waive any interest in each other’s estate plan, in order to permit the other spouse to address other family responsibilities.
Or, it could be that your spouse is dependent on your income and property. But, to fulfill family obligations, you may want to take care of your spouse for life, and have your property pass to your family upon her death. This can be addressed in a prenuptial or marital agreement.
Put Your Plan into Action
Finally, you need to develop the tools to put your plan into action. The tools could involve a trust to benefit your spouse during her life, but then pass the property to your children on her death. The tools could involve life insurance, and properly structuring the life insurance. These are all issues you should address with your estate planning attorney and other professionals, such as an accountant and financial advisor.
With proper communication and planning, you can balance your family obligations, and manage the expectations of your loved ones.
A blended family is one where either spouse has children from a prior marriage or relationship. Blended families raise estate planning issues because of the need to balance responsibilities to the current spouse, as well as to the children from the prior relationship.
Without special planning, you may find that you goals are not being met.
For example, in Virginia, where a person is married, but has children from a prior relationship, and that person dies without a will, then one-third of the estate passes to the current spouse, and two-thirds are split among all of the decedent’s children. Notice, by the way, that I specifically said “prior relationship,” and not “prior marriage.” That is in recognition that the law protects illegitimate children as much as legitimate children.
This default estate plan, which is called the law of intestacy, may cause some problems for your surviving loved ones. For example, if you have children from a prior marriage, but they are adults, and your current spouse depends on your income and property, the law of intestacy works against your current spouse.
The solution is to carefully think about your family responsibilities and your estate plan goals, talk about them with your spouse, and work with an estate planning attorney to make your goals happen. Here are some tips on how you may be able to achieve your estate planning goals.
Communicate with Your Spouse
The first step is to make sure that you and your spouse are on the same page. Talk openly about your responsibilities to your children from your prior relationship. Talk about your expectations for any children you may have in your current marriage. Talk about what property rights you have, and how you expect to dispose of those rights on your death.
Conclude a Prenuptial or Marital Agreement
Once you and your current spouse (or, ideally your future spouse) have discussed your respective responsibilities, you should come to an understanding concerning your property. Formalize that understanding with a prenuptial agreement (before the wedding) or marital agreement (after the wedding). In Virginia, a marital agreement is just as valid as a prenuptial agreement.
Many people will resist prenuptial agreements with their future spouses. Some view them as merely planning for an eventual divorce. Some of your friends, or even misinformed attorneys may echo that thought.
A prenuptial or marital agreement, however, is not simply planning for an eventual divorce. Rather, it can be a tool to start the conversation about property and expectations. It can be an opportunity to clarify estate planning goals. Formalizing the expectations in a written agreement can avoid confusion and misunderstandings later in the marriage.
For example, if both spouses are coming into a marriage with their own property, it could be that neither spouse would be dependent on the property of the other after one passes away. In such a situation, the spouses may agree to waive any interest in each other’s estate plan, in order to permit the other spouse to address other family responsibilities.
Or, it could be that your spouse is dependent on your income and property. But, to fulfill family obligations, you may want to take care of your spouse for life, and have your property pass to your family upon her death. This can be addressed in a prenuptial or marital agreement.
Put Your Plan into Action
Finally, you need to develop the tools to put your plan into action. The tools could involve a trust to benefit your spouse during her life, but then pass the property to your children on her death. The tools could involve life insurance, and properly structuring the life insurance. These are all issues you should address with your estate planning attorney and other professionals, such as an accountant and financial advisor.
With proper communication and planning, you can balance your family obligations, and manage the expectations of your loved ones.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)





